Pizza in Rock Hill is a dice roll. You might get a foldable New York slice at Richie’s, a greasy pepperoni roll that ruins dinner, or a brick of Chicago comfort at Heath Springs that demands a nap.

We ate our way past the strip malls and the brewery tap lists to find which pies deserve your actual money, not just your late-night cravings. A flatbread s'mores at Empire was a genuine revelation, and my kids still talk about Big Papa's.

The rankings are honest, and the judgments are final. Here’s the list.

Richie's Italian Bistro at Riverwalk

Highlights
Finally, real New York pizza
Friendly and inviting service
Amazing pepperoni rolls, honestly
Reasonably priced, decent dinner
Inconsistent pickup, sadly inconsistent

I walked into Richie's Italian Bistro at Riverwalk with low expectations and a growling stomach. The place looks like a strip-mall afterthought. Then the pepperoni rolls arrived. Honestly, they're the real deal, greasy, salty, with a kick of pepperoni that makes you forget the sad salad bar. The pizza itself is proper New York style, thin, foldable, and finally not a cracker. Service was friendly, even when the pickup counter seemed to lose my order twice. The price is right for a casual dinner, so I forgave the chaos. Just call ahead. Or don't. It's a gamble. But the good kind.

You might also want to check out the best pizza places in Charlotte.

The Pour Market

Highlights
Stylish interior, unexpected atmosphere
Friendly staff, great service
Salads worth returning for
An untapped Rock Hill find
Easy five-star experience

The Pour Market surprised me. I expected a bar with bad bar pizza. Instead, I found a stylish interior, all exposed brick and soft light, and a staff that actually smiled. The pizza was competent, but the salads are why I'm returning. I know, I know. A salad. But the dressing was bright, the greens crisp, and somehow it all felt intentional. The service was attentive without hovering, which is a rare skill. This place feels like a secret, even if it's not. Easy five stars. I almost felt guilty for enjoying it. Almost.

You might also want to check out the best pizza places in Spartanburg.

Vito's Pizza Shop

Highlights
Hot, fresh delivery
Excellent garlic sauce
Tasty, reliable pies
Good cheese bread

Vito's Pizza Shop is the reliable friend you forget about until you need them. The delivery arrived hot, which is a miracle in this town. The garlic sauce deserves its own poem, thick, buttery, and dangerous for your breath. The pies are simple and consistent, no fancy toppings, just solid cheese and sauce that tastes like it came from a can, but a good can. The cheese bread is a greasy joy. I ordered twice in one week. That's embarrassing. But I won't apologize. It's Vito's.

You might also want to check out the best pizza places in Denver.

Rock Hill Brewing Company

Highlights
Beer and pizza combo
Outstanding, knowledgeable service
Great tap selection
Ample seating and parking

Rock Hill Brewing Company pairs beer and pizza like they were made for each other, because they were. The tap list is impressive, hoppy and dark and everything between. The staff knows their beer, and they know their pizza. The crust is chewy with a char, the sauce is slightly sweet, and it all goes down easy with a local IPA. There's plenty of seating, and parking wasn't a nightmare. I stayed longer than I planned. The pizza is a vehicle for the beer. That's not an insult. It's a compliment.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Charlotte.

Fratelli

Highlights
Artichoke pizza wins skeptics
Attentive service, cozy atmosphere
Catering handled with expertise
Owner solves bruschetta challenge
Worth planning around hours

Fratelli made me eat my words. The artichoke pizza, which sounds like a punishment, won me over with its briny, creamy, weirdly perfect flavor. The service was attentive, the room felt cozy without being cramped. The owner personally solved a bruschetta problem that I didn't even know I had. Catering? They handled a party of twelve without breaking a sweat. The hours are odd, which is annoying, but I'll plan my life around them. That's how good this place is. I'm still thinking about that artichoke.

You might also want to check out the best shopping malls in Charlotte.

Two Scoops Rock Hill @ Junior Varsity

Highlights
Favorite ice cream in Rock Hill
Cool outdoor seating area
Amazing food and ice cream
Warm, caring owner and staff

Two Scoops Rock Hill is an ice cream shop that also serves pizza. That's a dangerous combination. The outdoor seating is cool, shaded, and perfect for a hot day. The owner and staff are warm, the kind of people who remember your name. The pizza is surprisingly good, but the ice cream is the real star. I had a slice and a scoop, and I felt like a child again. It's not fancy. It's not trying to be. It's just good food in a good mood. I left smiling. That's rare.

You might also want to check out the best companies to work for in Charlotte.

Empire Pizza Indian Land

Highlights
Service that truly cares
Memorable five-star experience
Desserts worth the hype
Generous, filling portions
New flatbread s'mores wow

Empire Pizza Indian Land is worth the drive, even if you're not from Indian Land. The service cares, genuinely, and that shows. The portions are generous, dangerously so. I ordered the flatbread s'mores for dessert, expecting a gimmick. It was a revelation, marshmallow and chocolate on crispy dough, and I ate the whole thing. The five-star experience is earned, not given. The staff anticipates your needs. The pizza itself is solid, but the desserts are the hype. I'm already planning my next trip.

You might also want to check out the best soul food in Charlotte.

Heath Springs Pizzeria

Highlights
Kind staff, exceptional service
Hand tossed and Chicago style
White cheese pizza favorite
Delicious house-made appetizers
Handles large parties gracefully

Heath Springs Pizzeria handles chaos with grace. I showed up with a large party, unannounced, and they didn't flinch. The staff is kind, the service is exceptional. The white cheese pizza is my favorite, creamy and salty and simple. The hand-tossed crust is light, but they also do a Chicago style that's a brick of comfort. The house-made appetizers, especially the breadsticks, are worth the trip alone. It's a small place, but it feels like a community. I left full and happy. That's all I ask.

You might also want to check out the best bar in Winston-Salem.

Big Papa's Pizzeria

Highlights
Best in the USA
Quality NY-style ingredients
Friendly engaging staff
Fresh ice for drinks
Kids' top choice

Big Papa's Pizzeria claims to be the best in the USA. I laughed. Then I took a bite. I stopped laughing. The crust is crisp, the sauce is bright, and the cheese is actually quality. The staff is friendly, engaging, and they keep your drink full with fresh ice, which sounds trivial but matters. My kids voted it their top choice, which means they won't stop talking about it. The ingredients feel New York-style, but the experience is all Southern hospitality. It's not the best in the country. But it's the best I've had in Rock Hill.

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Winston-Salem.

The Mercantile by Copper Dwelling & Design

Highlights
Pizza, plus side hustles.
Perfect for girls' outings.
Staff delivers flawless events.
Affordable wedding venue option.
Wine bar keeps people lingering.

The Mercantile is a pizza place that also does event planning, which is a weird combo that works. The pizza is fine, but the real product is the vibe. It's perfect for a girls' outing, all cute and curated. The staff pulls off events without a glitch, which is rare. They even do weddings here, on a budget, and it looks affordable. The wine bar keeps people lingering, and I lingered for two hours. It's not a traditional pizzeria, but it's a place where you'll eat well and forget the time.

You might also want to check out the best goodwill in Charlotte.

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor (Colony road)

Highlights
Crispy crust, perfect sauce
Garlic knots are the move
Reminds me of childhood pizza
Helpful counter service
Classic cheese pizza done right

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor on Colony Road transported me back to childhood, in the best way. The crust is crispy, with a slight chew, and the sauce is perfectly balanced, not too sweet, not too acidic. The garlic knots are the move, buttery and dense and addictive. The counter service is helpful, even when I couldn't decide. The classic cheese pizza is simple, done right. It's the kind of pizza that doesn't need toppings to impress. I ate three slices and felt no shame. It's nostalgic, but it's also just good.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Hickory.

Intermezzo

Highlights
Top three pizzas in city
Spotless restrooms appreciated
Best pizza, perfect service
Great cocktails, friendly staff
Convenient parking lot bonus

Intermezzo is a top three pizza in this city, and I don't say that lightly. The restrooms are spotless, which is a sign of discipline. The service is perfect, attentive without being intrusive. The cocktails are great, well made and strong. The parking lot is convenient, which is a luxury in Rock Hill. The pizza itself is excellent, a thin, blistered crust with a tangy sauce. I've had better, but not many. I'll be back. I'll bring friends. I'll order the same thing. It's that reliable.

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Charlotte.